The Bears Conservative Approach to Free Agency Is the Right One

Ryan Poles.jpg

Phil Thompson at the Chicago Tribune on the Bears conservative approach to free agency:

[GM Ryan] Poles is taking the long view, not serving a short-term bid for a Super Bowl run that might not materialize next season. And then a season or two later, you’re in salary-cap hell with a roster of aging or injury-riddled stars.

The champion Seattle Seahawks were a model of building steadily but fairly quickly, with hardly a household name among their number.

Poles acknowledged he has to consider: “What’s going to help this football team now? But also being conscious of what’s going to happen down the road.”

“We want to sustain success,” he continued. “We talk about that a lot. In order to do that, we have to be very calculated with the moves we make. We felt like sticking with our plan going into free agency, that was the best thing for us.”

For years, Bears fans clamored for the team to be big players in free agency. And I’d say over the last 10 years that they have been with some big signings and big trades. And look where it’s got them. Not very far. Lots of big swings. Some hits. A lot of misses. I’m looking at you, Chase Claypool.

These largely expensive moves that have drained their resources have generally gotten them nowhere for very long.

Good franchises that are competitive year after year in the long term generally don’t operate that way. I look at teams like the Steelers, for instance, and I don’t see them out there chasing expensive free agents. These are draft and develop organizations that are very strategic in their free agent signings.

The Bears had that in the Jerry AngeloLovie Smith days of the franchise, and though they weren’t competing for a Super Bowl every year, they competed within the division more often than not.

Now the Bears appear to me to be set up better than they were in the Angelo days because they appear to me to have a better coaching staff with an offensive head coach that can compare favorably with anyone in the league.

The Bears are truly set up for sustained success. Now is not the time to go all in. The Bears need to be about value now.

It’s the time to get the best deal you can for under-the-radar talent and to let the organization make that talent worth more than what you paid for. That’s what good organizations do, and that’s what the team has to become.

Posted in Chicago Bears | 2 Comments

Sometimes Good Teams Have to Make More Out of What The Have

Braxton Jones Similing.jpg

Brad Biggs at the Chicago Tribune on the left tackle situation headed into the draft:

It’s not unlike the spot the franchise found itself in last offseason, sorting through a handful of options to play the position. There’s an injured player in the mix again, this time Ozzy Trapilo, who will miss at least a good chunk of the season as he recovers from a torn patellar tendon in his left knee. The Bears probably need to prepare for the possibility that Trapilo, a second-round pick in 2025, won’t be in the mix until 2027.

The difference this time around is the coaching staff has two experienced players to evaluate: Braxton Jones, who signed his one-year contract Friday, and Jedrick Wills Jr., a first-round pick (No. 10) of the Cleveland Browns in 2020.

Add Theo Benedet — who made eight starts last season, including seven at left tackle — and even Kiran Amegadjie into the mix and it’s unlikely the Bears will look at a left tackle with their first-round draft pick next month.

I think that what these moves tell me more than anything is that they don’t anticipate that a potential left tackle will be the best player on the board when the time comes for their pick. It also suggests to me that they don’t see the possibility of trading up for one.

As I talk to fans in the neighborhood and around the Internet, I hear a lot of hand-wringing over the state of the left tackle position. “Surely, they aren’t planning to go into the season with these guys! Surely they aren’t done!” After asking them not to call me Shirley, I try to point out to them that they very well might be done.

How many people reading this post thought going into last season that Nashon Wright would be tied for second in the NFL in interceptions with five? How many thought that Kevin Byard was going to be a first-team All-Pro?

Fans always want to see all pros at every position, and I do, too. But sometimes you can’t just buy those guys off the shelf. Sometimes you have to make them. And the more that time goes on and the more you have to pay players like Caleb Williams, the more of them you have to make.

That’s what good teams do.

I would describe Jones as “serviceable” when healthy. About league average, give or take five spots. Most would describe Wills as, perhaps, even a bit better.

Can the Bears make them better than that? Perhaps with good coaching they can. But even if they can’t, good coaches like Ben Johnson can make “serviceable” work. They have to. That’s their job. Because you can’t have a top-paid NFL player at every position.

Sometimes good teams have to work with what they have.

Posted in Chicago Bears | Leave a comment

Will Kyler Murray Really Be the Answer in Minnesota?

Dave Campbell writing for the Chicago Tribune on the Vikings acquisition of quarterback Kyler Murray after he was cut by the Cardinals:

Murray, despite being sidetracked by recent injuries and dogged by questions about his work ethic, has two Pro Bowl selections, a 67% career completion percentage — and a bonus of 3,193 rushing yards with 32 touchdowns.

After winning the Heisman Trophy at Oklahoma, Murray was voted the NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year and appeared to have the Cardinals on the upswing. He produced multiple electrifying highlights such as the “Hail Murray” in 2020, when he connected with DeAndre Hopkins for a game-winning touchdown pass against the Buffalo Bills on the game’s final play. Murray passed for 400 yards in a Week 2 win over the Vikings in 2021, when the Cardinals started 10-2 before finishing 11-6.

The Cardinals signed Murray to five-year, $230.5 million contract in 2022 with $160 million guaranteed, but the honeymoon after that hefty commitment was short. A few weeks after the deal was done, the Cardinals removed a strange clause in the contract that mandated four hours of “independent study” during game weeks. The kerfuffle called into question Murray’s work habits, and his relationship with the franchise was never the same.

My impression of Murray is that he’s been incredibly inconsistent his whole career. Although it’s hard to know from the outside looking in, it’s not hard to conclude that this stems from poor work habits. Anyone who threw anything at Murray that he didn’t expect likely had success against him.

There’s no denying Murray’s talent, and I think that Minnesota head coach Kevin O’Connell is a pretty good quarterback coach. It’s entirely possible that Murray will experience a renaissance under him and have a good year. But long term, Murray is unlikely to be the answer for any team as long as computer games supersede the kind of dedication to the game that seems to be required for most successful NFL quarterbacks.

I have serious doubts that the Vikings have solved their quarterback problem.

Posted in Chicago Bears | Leave a comment

The D.J. Moore Trade was no Surprise. But the Compensation Was.

Brad Biggs at the Chicago Tribune on which trade or signing surprised him during the free agent portion of the offseason:

None of the moves really came across as surprising. It was eye-opening the Bears got a second-round pick from the Buffalo Bills for [D.J.] Moore and a fifth-round pick. As openly as the Bears discussed the possibility of trading Moore, it became pretty evident they were telling everyone, “Come make us an offer.” The Bears liked Moore, but they needed the cap space the move created. Given they were so open about trading him, getting a second-rounder back was impressive even if they had to ship a fifth to Buffalo. Maybe the Bills feared Ryan Poles could put together a deal with the division rival Patriots, who also needed receivers.

I, too, was surprised by this. But my gut feeling was that in order to get such a good deal, the Bears would have to eat some of Moore’s $23.5 million base salary. Which would, of course, defeat the purpose of the trade.

It looked to me like Bears head coach Ben Johnson never really knew what to do with Moore. He’s not particularly big and he’s not particularly fast, and he wasn’t a particularly good fit for anything that Johnson wanted to do. Moore probably would have been OK as a #3 receiver in Johnson’s offense, but he was being paid to be a good #1 receiver. That’s why Johnson was doing things like putting Moore into the backfield as a running back in order to maximize his value. It was an awkward situation.

Bills head coach Joe Brady was the offensive coordinator for the Carolina Panthers in 2020–2021 when Moore was a starting wide receiver for the team. Brady might very well have a better idea of how to use Moore to maximize his production.

Still, you have to wonder who the Bills were bidding against at that salary for Moore.

So, yes, the compensation that the Bears received was a surprise. Nevertheless, this looks like it could be a trade that could work out well for both sides.

Posted in Chicago Bears | Leave a comment

New Coaches and Old Friends

Brad Biggs at the Chicago Tribune goes over changes to the Bears staff for the 2026 season.

Press Taylor will be offensive coordinator after spending last year as the passing game coordinator. Eric Studesville has been named running backs coach. He spent nine seasons with the Miami Dolphins, overlapping there for two years with Ben Johnson. Will Lawing, who was teammates with Johnson at North Carolina, will be an offensive analyst. Isaiah Ford was hired as an offensive quality control assistant. Ford was drafted as a wide receiver by the Dolphins in 2017. Johnson was a Miami wide receivers coach in 2017 and 2018..

Its not a big deal, especially this year when two of the assistants (Lawing and Ford) are low on the coaching pathway, but is always bothers me when new staff additions all have previous connections to the head coach.

I get it. These are people you know and are comfortable with. But it always makes you wonder if the best people for the job are being hired. You’d like to eventually see Johnson branch out to find new blood. Otherwise, the quality coaching staff will eventually degrade.

Admittedly, in the meantime, Johnson is the most important member of the staff and it’s entirely possible that he, as head coach will be driving them to a better than average quality.

Posted in Chicago Bears | Leave a comment

The Bears Can’t Rest With the Idea that They Have a Good Defensive Line When Healthy

Brad Biggs at the Chicago Tribune addresses what the Super Bowl can teach the Bears. He highlights needs along the defensive line:

While it’s true that general manager Ryan Poles needs to address the defensive line beginning next month, it’s not like he didn’t make an effort last year. The Bears signed tackle Grady Jarrett and end Dayo Odeyingbo in free agency. They just didn’t provide the kind of high-level play the Bears got from the interior linemen they added on the offensive side. Jarrett battled through a right knee injury, and Odeyingbo suffered a torn Achilles tendon. Rookie end Shemar Turner, a second-round pick, was lost to a torn ACL.

Even with all three healthy, the Bears need some combination of upgrades and competition to elevate the profile of [defensive coordinator, Dennis] Allen’s defense. The timing is right because it’s a solid draft for defensive linemen.

There is a danger here for the Bears. With limited resources they might think that they fixed the defensive line last year and that injuries simply derailed the plan. But injuries are a part of the game and all that tells me is that they didn’t have enough depth.

Odeyingbo was a disappointment even when he was on the field. Turner, a second round pick from the 2025 draft, is still a mystery but the Bears haven’t had a good record of drafting defensive linemen in recent years. Gervon Dexter, drafted by Poles in the second round in 2023, hasn’t set the world on fire and Zach Pickens, drafted in the third round the same year, isn’t even on the team. Austin Booker, drafted in the fifth round in 2025, had a good year but it looked to me like he was schemed into the sacks he got with too many free runs at the quarterback. He hasn’t shown me the ability to beat an offensive lineman one-on-one with any consistency and that’s what the Bears need a lot more of.

With no cap space to spare this offseason, the Bears have to draft better or they’ll struggle to remain competitive with a tougher schedule and a considerably bigger challenge coming up next year.

Posted in Chicago Bears | Leave a comment

Why Kyler Gordon Is So Important to the Bears Defense

Ted Nguyen at The Athletic on why the secret to a great defense is having a premium nickel:

Obviously, with the rise of pass-heavy offenses and three-receiver personnel, a third corner who can cover slot receivers is important, but with how good modern offenses are at creatively using their personnel, the demands of a nickel are as high as ever. Eagles defensive coordinator Vic Fangio and Seahawks head coach Mike Macdonald run a system that’s become the trendiest in the league. A core tenet of that system is being able to defend the run from light boxes and sub personnel (five or more defensive backs). To do that, the nickel has to be a third linebacker at times.

Also, offenses have trended toward throwing to the middle of the field, so the nickel will almost always be closest to the ball on run and pass. You want your best player to be consistently in the action. In 2009, Hall of Famer Charles Woodson won the defensive player of the year award after moving inside, which was a position change that was well ahead of its time. In 2020, Jalen Ramsey had a similar impact playing the star position, which is what Nick Saban-influenced systems call nickels. True multi-tool nickels don’t grow on trees, but the best defenses in the league have one, and moving your best defensive back there can pay dividends.

…The nickel position has evolved so much that coaches might even dedicate a specialized coach to them.

“I do think that’s something I would consider at the next place,” [Chargers defensive coordinator Jesse]** Minter** said. “For us, our secondary often meets together, and so they’re in that room from a pass-coverage standpoint. They’re with the safeties during some drills, they’re with corners during some drills. We’d get with the linebackers in certain run fit situations.”

As is usually the case with Nguyen, there are specific examples and plays that are demonstrated to back up his point. The whole article is worth a read.

This is why the Bears so badly missed Kyler Gordon, who was lost to injury for most of the season. They tried to get by with Nick McCloud and C.J. Gardner-Johnson but they didn’t have anyone on the roster that had the versatility to play the nickel cornerback position as it’s being played in the most modern NFL defenses. Nickel backs have have the versatility to be able to play cornerback, safety, off-ball linebacker and, in some cases, pass rusher. That kind of versatility is hard to find. The Bears couldn’t find it without Gordon.

It’s going to be interesting to see what defensive coordinator Dennis Allen does with this defense once he has everyone healthy. I also wonder if the Bears won’t be looking for more depth at the nickel position beyond Gordon. In an ideal world, Allen would hav more than one player who can fill in to get the job done. Such players may be tough to find now, however. Again, from Nguyen:

So, where do you find these types of players? The truth is, they are very rare, akin to finding great quarterbacks. You can find 32 guys who can play the position, but there are maybe five to 10 nickels who are truly exceptional game-changers. And if they are available in the draft, they should be bona fide first-round picks.

“The value of a great nickel is way higher than what most personnel departments think,” [Eagles safeties coach Joe] Kasper said. “Most personnel departments are really way behind the times. They think that they need the outside guy first and the inside guy second, and you know that inside piece is really a mid-round type guy. I totally disagree (with their going that low), the way that the game is going. When you look at it, you look at these offenses that run in-breaking routes off of reductions, and then that is already defeating quarter leverage. And then we talk like, ‘Oh, well, the corner is still the most important one.’ I just think that that’s grossly inaccurate if you’re talking about keeping up with the times.”

Posted in Chicago Bears | Leave a comment

Brief comments: Rams at Bears 1/18/26

I watched the game last night with friends and, therefore, didn’t take notes. They know I’m a geek but there’s not reason to make it that obvious.

Nevertheless, here are a few brief comments from the game.

  • So, so many drops. Drops are like huge penalties because you lose the yardage and the down. It’s hard to win when you have so many of them, and they were lucky to do it last week.
  • Having said that, Caleb Williams didn’t exactly make it easy on the receivers yesterday. A lot of the balls that he threw could’ve been a lot more catchable under the circumstances. He wasn’t very accurate and that’s been the case on and off all season. Something to work on in the offseason, maybe.
  • Speaking of the cold weather, I thought the Rams looked like the cold weather team yesterday. It was the Bears, who were having trouble holding onto the ball and, in Williams’s case, throwing it. I thought that was interesting, though I don’t have an explanation for it.
  • The play calling inside the 10-yard line wasn’t my favorite. The Bears pounded the ball inside and they were getting nowhere. Not only that, but after doing it over and over again when they finally threw a pass from inside the five, they did it from the shotgun and didn’t use play action. I usually don’t question playcalling as a rule, but I do kind of wonder what they were thinking.
  • It’s really pathetic that I’ve watched this game all my life and I still don’t know what a catch looks like. I can’t look at the non-interception by the Bears defense yesterday and then look at the somewhat infamous interception by Denver over a Buffalo player the day before and reconcile the two.
  • Nice effort for the defense. All year long I have to say that I bagged on them. They worried me every game, and there were a lot of games where I didn’t think the Bears would win because I thought that the defensive line was so poor. But they held up pretty well yesterday. Kudos to them.
  • I can’t remember exactly what my prediction was, but I know it wasn’t more than eight wins for the season. It was a wonderful, magical year. I enjoyed every minute of it.
Posted in Chicago Bears | 1 Comment

After a Few Early Season Struggles Caleb Williams Is Throwing Fine From the Left

Brad Biggs at the Chicago Tribune has 10 thoughts after the Bears Win over the Packers last Sunday. Here he addresses quarterback Caleb Williams’ 4th and 8 throw to wise receiver Rome Odunze in the 4th quarter:

It’s a big-time throw at any point in a ballgame. With the situation — fourth-and-8 with the Bears on their 43 and trailing 27-16 with 5:37 to play — the stakes couldn’t get much bigger. Fail to convert there, and Green Bay takes over on the plus side of the field with a chance to ice the game. The Packers rushed only four.

“He’s a guy that’s tough to contain,” [Packers head coach] Matt LaFleur said of Williams. “The whole plan was to try to especially eliminate his ability to go right. That’s what he likes to do. But certainly, I mean, he made a heck of a play, heck of a throw.”

LaFleur would have had a point earlier in the season. Williams was constantly looking to roll to his right and he was struggling to throw accurately when forced to go left. It awkward for any right handed quarterback to do that because you are turning to your right, against the momentum to the left, to square up and pass with any strength.

But this is outdated information now. Williams has been rolling to his left for a few weeks now and he’s been on the money more times than not. It’s still awkward and you can tell that because he literally jumped in the air with the “Jordan pose” to make the Odunze throw. But he’s got a tremendous amount of arm strength and he can use it to his advantage more than most quarterbacks in this situation.

Bottom line, I don’t think Williams is as hesitant to roll left as LaFluer thinks and I don’t think it hinders him as much as some people who were watching earlier in the year might be thinking.

Posted in Chicago Bears | Leave a comment

Brief Comments: Packers at Bears 1/10/26

Sorry. I was offline most of yesterday. It being a night game didn’t help, and I actually had to finish watching it this morning. As regular readers will know, I don’t usually post comments after night games, but this was a special one, and I couldn’t help myself.

  • I thought going for it on fourth so deep in their own territory in the first half was crazy. And it wasn’t like it was fourth and one. It was relatively a long way. But I guess that’s what Ben Johnson believes in. Green Bay was kicking the defense‘s butt so badly that you kind of felt like if the Bears didn’t score, they were going to have no chance even at that point in the game.

  • Way, way too many drops on both sides yesterday. It killed the Bears in the first half and hurt them later, too. I believe it literally killed the Packers at the end of the game.

  • I thought the Bears missed a lot of opportunities on missed turnovers, and I was surprised that Williams threw two interceptions. He’s not prone to do that. But at least one of them was a fourth down where it turned out to effectively be the same as a punt.

  • The defense started to blitz more after the half, and it was so nice to see them start to get a little pressure. Green Bay eventually adjusted, but what did the Bears have to lose, right? It also got them a little bit more penetration against the run, and I think it had an effect on some of those outside run plays where they were using their speed to outrun the Bears’ defense.

  • I feel bad for him, but at the same time, thank you, Brandon McManus.

  • I think decades of frustration got released yesterday, and I was glad to see so much of the celebrating going on. But I wish that the players and Johnson hadn’t done quite so much trolling of the Packers after the game. I know the Packers had said some things that didn’t sit well with them, but, personally, I’d much rather just quietly and happily get off the field and let the other team say nice things about you. But that’s just me. I guess the modern athlete (and coach) just doesn’t think that way.

Great game!

Posted in Chicago Bears | Leave a comment