Bear(ing) the News – A Chicago Bears Blog

• Brad Biggs at the Chicago Tribune answers your questions:

While the pass-rush problem seems like an issue that isn’t likely to be resolved with this team’s personnel, are there solutions to fixing the run defense in scheme and personnel? Getting Kyler Gordon back should help, but does Nahshon Wright need to be replaced if he continues to show zero interest in stopping the run? — @chicityforum1

I wrote at length earlier this week about the team’s struggles stopping the run. Fortunately it’s still a small sample size as the Bears have played only four games, but it has been an ominous start considering the explosive plays they are allowing on the ground. They are allowing 6.15 yards per carry. That’s last in the league and more than a half-yard behind the 31st-ranked Miami Dolphins.

“Hopefully (Gordon’s return) allows us to unlock a few things on defense,” Ben Johnson said. “He’s one of our bigger playmakers. I’ve got a lot of experience being on the opposing sideline from him and a ton of respect for how he can impact the game. There’s only a handful of nickels in this league that you really have to account for both as a coverage player but also a guy that likes to be nosy in the run game, and (he) could be part of the solution for us in terms of shoring up our run game as well.

“He’s got those natural football instincts that are really hard to coach and hard to teach. When you have enough players like that, that’s where you really take off in a hurry.”

Wright isn’t going to be great in run defense. I didn’t see a lack of interest in aiding the run defense last time out in Las Vegas. I saw him taking poor angles and failing to get outside leverage. He was coming down into the box. He just wasn’t executing.

As you probably know, cornerbacks are judged first by their ability to defend the pass, and if you’re swapping out those guys because of the problems you have stopping the run, there are probably bigger issues at hand.

Biggs has a point. But cornerbacks do play a role in stopping the run, and where stopping the run is a major issue, as it is with the Bears, Wright’s deficiencies in this area cannot be ignored. He has to be aggressive, stopping the run on the outside and helping to defend big plays.

Having said that, the outside run isn’t the only issue the Bears have. They’ve been porous all over the place up and down the defense.

Problems stopping the run are almost always due to poor fundamentals. Either guys aren’t doing their job filling the proper gaps or there is poor tackling, or they are having a hard time getting off of blocks. In the Bears’ case, it’s probably all three. In particular, the tackling is falling apart late in games in part because they’re just getting tired.

To an extent, I think all of these are correctable issues. I look forward to seeing if the Bears’ run defense improves coming off of the bye week after a prolonged period of self-scouting.

• Biggs goes on to address the Bears running game.

Do you think this is a week we finally start to see more Kyle Monangai in the offense? — @j_toast

Monangai’s playing time was pretty similar in the last two games: 17 snaps against the Cowboys and 19 against the Raiders. He had 28 in Week 2 in Detroit, but that bump was largely attributable to the lopsided score in the second half.

We’ll have to see after Monangai appeared on the initial injury report of the week Thursday. It was an estimate because the team was off Thursday, but he was listed as “did not participate” with a thigh injury.

When he’s healthy, I’m of the mindset that Monangai’s playing time will depend somewhat on game flow. By that, I mean if the coaching staff has a plan entering the game to use him on the fourth offensive series of the first half and the third series of the second half, how does the offense do in those scenarios? If it’s a sustained drive, there will be opportunities for more snaps and more touches.

He’ll get mixed in on occasion for D’Andre Swift in the middle of a drive. Ben Johnson has been pretty clear: He’s not piling the blame for an inconsistent rushing attack on Swift’s shoulders. Plus, Swift has been a consistent check-down target for Caleb Williams. He has 13 receptions and the ability to make a big play in the passing game.

Maybe we’ll see a few more touches for Monangai, but I don’t know that handing him the ball more would all of a sudden unlock the offense.

Rookie running backs tend to struggle as pass protectors in the NFL. It’s not that I’ve noticed that Monangai is particularly bad at it. But Swift is extremely good at it, and that’s going to be a major advantage to keeping Swift more of the time in Johnson’s mind.

I know that many Bears fans are going to choose the obvious and blame Swift for the poor running attack. But I tend to beleave Johnson when he says that Swift isn’t really the issue.

“It’s hard to evaluate any of our running backs right now when you turn on the tape and there’s some free runners in the hole where the play’s designed to go,” Johnson said. “I take it personally because I actually spend more time on the run game than I do on the passing game. Not only trying to create explosives in the running game but being sound and taking a lot of pride in our execution of the fundamentals.”

“You talk about a deuce block, deuce combination, all looking the same, a triple between the tight end and the tackle all looking the same,” Johnson said. “We’re not quite there yet. It’s been a race since training camp started. We get pads on, that’s when the full speed starts happening, and you get linebackers that are coming downhill and pulling you off your double teams. We’re just not reacting fast enough right now.”

As Johnson says, it appears to me that the Bears’ problems running the ball are those of execution. What he hasn’t said is that he’s running a fairly complicated offense that, unlike those the Bears fans have been exposed to in the recent past, is going to take a while for them to get comfortable with. This goes for both a running game and the passing game, and it’s probably responsible for some of the pre-snap penalties that they’re committing right now as well.

It appears to me that Bears fans are just going to have to be patient here. If the offense still looks like it does now halfway through next year, then I think they’ll be cause for concern. In the meantime, we just have to wait.

• Kevin Fishbain at The Athletic was also answering questions this week.

Which of our tackles would project well as guards in terms of physical statistics and skill set? Would love to find a long-term solution at right guard as I don’t think we have found even a medium-term solution in Jonah Jackson. — Nancy K.

After receiving a few questions about Jackson, I surmise that his PFF grade is low. He does have four penalties this season, which isn’t good, but I don’t think his play is anywhere near the “bench the $17 million player” territory. However, to the question about future options, if Kiran Amegadjie can get (and stay) healthy, I’d be curious what he can do at guard. That’s a big “if” based on how his career has gone, but the Bears started using him there late in the summer and liked what they saw. And then there’s rookie Luke Newman, who impressed in camp and the preseason and can play center. Those two stand out to me more than asking any of the current tackles to move inside.

This is a good question by Nancy, and I thought Fishbain’s response about “surmising that his PFF grade is low“ was a bit unfairly dismissive. Fans watch the games too, and we see what we see.

It hasn’t gotten a lot of attention, but I think that Jackson is definitely underperforming, and I would say that his job is probably in some danger. Like Fishbain, I think that there are possibly better options on the Bears roster as it stands right now.

I would guess that the Bears will give the offensive line a little bit more of a chance to gel in the running game as I urged fans to do above. But I wonder if that is going to solve Jackson’s problem, given that he couldn’t keep a starting job in Los Angeles. It will be interesting to see what happens here.

• I’m currently writing this at halftime of the Jets-Broncos game in London, so I may regret this later. But this all looks so familiar. It’s like PTSD with Justin Fields.

They started the pre-game off with all these really impressive statistics about Fields’ passer rating and the fact that he has no interceptions. And yet I watch and I see the Broncos doing everything against him that other teams did when they played the Bears and he was the quarterback. Try to keep him in the pocket. Cover everyone on the back end. Let him run if he can escape, knowing that you simply can’t win games that way.

He’s got this great passer rating against the blitz, but who cares? Who in the world would blitz this guy? All you have to do is let him drop back and hold the ball, and the drives end themselves.

• Brad Biggs at the Chicago Tribune discusses the return of Austin Booker and the state of the pass rush:

Despite missing the final exhibition game, Booker led the NFL with four sacks in the preseason, and the Bears were optimistic that the gains they saw him make over the offseason and in training camp would carry into the regular season. He had 1½ sacks and four QB hits in 17 games as a rookie but looked more refined and powerful in the preseason.

“You felt the pass rush there, particularly in the game setting,” coach Ben Johnson said before practice Tuesday. “I saw it in practice and the joint practices as well. He was a guy that was able to affect the quarterback. That’s something that we talked about as a unit today: points of emphasis, where can we improve. Obviously it’s the penalties, it’s the run game, but affecting the quarterback, we’re not doing a good enough job of it.

“That’s really where I saw Booker making the biggest impact in the preseason. We’ll have to see where he is now back on the practice field.”

Booker seems to me to be a leaky vessel to be pouring the Bears pass rush hopes into.

Ultimately, when you are holding your breath hoping that a fifth rounder comes through for you, this comes down to poor drafting. The Bears have spent resources trying to build the defensive line up. They just haven’t panned out (I’m looking at you, Gervon Dexter, Zach Pickens and possibly Shemar Turner).

It’s possible that it’s just been poor coaching across the board. But I think it’s more likely that those in the front office are eventually going to have to take a long lookin the mirror.

• Biggs also spent his bye week looking at the run defense.

Getting two core players back will help, for sure, but it’s not as if the Bears are going to have reinforcements who make a big difference on the line… The linemen need to start defeating blocks, cutting through double-teams and holding their ground.

“The most important thing that we’re looking at as a staff and as players is, how do we get better at some of our fundamentals?” Ben Johnson said. “We’re not shedding blocks to the degree we’d like to yet, or at least as consistently as we’d like to yet. We’re not making tackles in space as well as we’re capable of.

This week is where we find out a lot about what kind of stuff Johnson has assembled. They are being challenged to correct these issues against Washington and they’ve been given the time during the bye to take a long look to figure out what where the problems are and how to solve them. The defensive personnel that Matt Eberflus ran with last year isn’t that much different than the personnel that they are going with now. And that defense wasn’t too bad early in the year.

I’ll be fascinated to see what this team looks like Monday night.

• Biggs answers your questions:

Ozzy Trapilo looked good enough at right tackle to start. What about moving Darnell Wright to left tackle to replace Braxton Jones and using Theo Benedet as the swing tackle? — Chris R., Midlothian

A good number of folks wondered the same thing. Jones is headed to the bench for the Week 6 game at Washington and, I believe, Benedet will be the man to replace him…

Switching Wright to the left side is something the Bears mulled publicly before the start of the offseason program. Then, we never saw him there. Jones, Trapilo, Kiran Amegadjie and finally Benedet all took turns at left tackle over the summer. That clearly told us the team’s preference was to keep Wright at right tackle.

Wright has been a little up and down this season, which isn’t unlike his first two years in the league. He can be an absolute physical force in the run game. Coach Ben Johnson recently raved about Wright’s elite athleticism for an offensive lineman and talked about doing stuff to get him in space in the running game because he moves so well.

However, Wright can be prone to lapses in play, something that hopefully smooths out soon because if you’re still saying that about a player going into Year 4, chances are that’s always going to be an issue.

Despite missing Week 4, he’s tied with Kansas City Chiefs right tackle Jawaan Taylor for the most penalties in the league with six. Wright has been called for two false starts, two holds (one was super iffy in Week 1), one illegal man downfield and a chop block.

Asking him to switch sides in the middle of the season and coming off an injury probably isn’t Plan A at Halas Hall. Instinct tells me Benedet, who played left tackle when Jones was removed from the game against the Raiders in the second quarter, will get the next shot at the job.

Could Wright be a consideration before the end of the season? Anything is possible, but if the Bears really liked this option, they probably would have been more proactive in the offseason when four other players got a shot on the left side.?

If Benedet falters, the Bears might try Trapilo again at left tackle before switching Wright.

Before training began I was in the camp that thought Trapilo would be starting at right tackle and that Wright would switch over to the left.

However, after watching the Wright struggle so much with the new offense to the point where he can’t concentrate enough to stay onside jumping. I think that he might struggle to make the switch.

I think it’s very possible that the coaching staff made the right call here. But it is very unfortunate because it has left them without a great option at left tackle. Perhaps they’re counting upon some improvement from Tripoli in the offseason that would make him more comfortable on the left. In the meantime, I think they’re just going to have to struggle to get by.

• Kevin Fishbain at The Athletic takes a statistical look at quarterback Caleb Williams.

When Williams is in rhythm, we see the precision, but there have been too many throws that aren’t giving his receivers a chance.

That comes with consistent footwork and comfort with the scheme.

“I would just say my footwork and then just being more comfortable with everything that Ben and the guys have thrown at me, just being able to grasp it all,

The Bears saids that they threw everything at Williams “to see what he cold handle” in training camp and what struck me is that those were almost the same words that Eberflus and his staff used to describe what they did with Williams last year.

But, unlike last year, Williams has improved and looked far more comfortable every game. And this is the difference between good coaching and poor coaching. Johnson and his staff overloaded Williams, then helped give him to tools to handle it. Last year, no one on the staff had the experience to know how to do that.

Fishbain also highlighted a pile of stats in the article. But the one I’m paying the most attention to is EPA versus the blitz. This has vastly improved since last year (-0.01 in 2024 and 0.22 in 2025, currently 10th in the league). This, again, I think is a good indication of both Williams potential and the coaching that he’s getting. Good quarterbacks in the NFL are good against the blitz.

I look forward to seeing Williams reach his full potential under this coaching staff as he, and the entire offense, gets more and more comfortable with the playbook. It won’t happen fast. But I’m happy to wait knowing that there’s a light at the end of the tunnel.

Offense

• The Bears were without Darnell Wright today and started Theo Benedet in his place. Benedet had a rough day but not because he didn’t play well. It was because he was dealing with Maxx Crosby all day. Ozzy Trapilo was inserted the last series in the first half. Benedet switched to the left in place of Braxton Jones. I was never clear on what happened to Jones. It may have been performance related but he hasn’t been healthy this year.
• Crosby was a monster in this game. Batted passes, tackles, sacks, and even an interception. He was all over Caleb Williams and D’Andre Swift. He was a massive problem for the Bears offense. Eventually they started to flat out double team him on every play towards the end of the first half.
• Williams was under pressure all day today and not just by Crosby. The Bears offensive line had a very difficult time keeping the Raiders out of the offensive backfield and they smothered the Bears.
• Similarly, the Bears just could not get their run game going. Swift was constantly being hit in the backfield before he had a chance to make a play.
• Ben Johnson apparently really likes to try to get Williams out on the naked boot but I’ve yet to see it work. Opposing defenses are all over it and the Raiders are no exception.
• Williams did a good job on occasion against the blitz today. He tends to look to Olamide Zaccheaus over the middle when pressured. I thought that Adam Achuleta’s criticism of Williams was unfair. He was a bit more than “uncomfortable” today. He was under siege. I thought he did about as well as you could expect under the circumstances.
• It appears that Williams was finding Cole Kmet more often today which is a step forward. On the other hand it was midway through the 4th quarter before he found DJ Moore.
• I would also say that, although he still missed a few, Williams was a bit more accurate today, another step forward.
• A couple series that tell a story today. 12:14 left in the second quarter. 1st and 10 from LV 24. Fumble recovery for a loss of 6 yards, followed by a sack for a loss of 10 yards. Punt instead of field goal. 6:51 left in the second, first and 10 from the Las Vegas 14, -2 yard run, second and 12 from the Las Vegas 16, 0 yard run, third and 12 from Las Vegas 16, 10 yard penalty, third and 22 from the Las Vegas 26, -2 yard run, field goal instead of a touchdown. This was the story of the game offensively.

Defense

• The Bears started this game without Jaylon Johnson and Kyler Gordon in the defensive backfield and without Grady Jarrett and Chris Williams on the defensive line. These were already weak areas of the defense. They were also without TJ Edwards but fortunately Noah Sewell has proven to be a good back up.
• Andrew Billings had a good day against the Raiders center, beating him on both 3rd and 4th and 1 in the first quarter and generally clogging up the middle when he was in there.
• Having said that, the defensive line struggled today. Ashton Jeanty broke out to have a good day as the Bears were his get right game along with the Raiders offensive line.
• Kevin Byard had himself a day against Raiders quarterback Geno Smith. Smith threw the ball to Byard twice in the first half after late changes in coverage that Smith evidently had a difficult time with.
• Miserable day for Smith today with multiple interceptions. He appeared to me to be having a difficult time adjusting to late, pre snap coverages by the Bears. Nice job by Byard and Tyrique Stevenson taking advantage.
• Give credit to Stevenson today. He threw his body around in a very high effort game.
• As the game wore on, late in the 3rd quarter into the 4th, I thought that there were too many missed tackles. This isn’t the first time this season that I thought that the Bears defense looked tired late in the game.
• Honestly, as weak as this defense was on both on the back end and, especially, up front even before injuries, it’s astounding that they’ve managed to perform as well as they have. It’s tough to watch at times.

Miscellaneous

• Bears fans didn’t take over the standout today but you could hear them when they had something to cheer about. I think estimates that it would be 50% Bears fans may have been over blown, though.
• I loved the interview from Johnson coming out of half time. To say he was a bit snippy with Aditi Kinkhabwala is a little bit of an understatement. One look at Johnson on the sideline tells you how much he hates losing.
• The Bears special teams did well today. Huge big play with the blocked field goal at the end and none given up. Cairo Santos has a good day. Tory Taylor kicked the ball off at the end of the game with less than 2 minutes left and a 1 point lead.
• The Bears didn’t commit what I would call an excessive number of penalties but they combine with all of the with other mistakes to kill drives. Not as many are pre-snap penalties as at the beginning of the season but this has to get cleaned up if they are going to beat good teams.
• The Bears won the turnover battle but the game was characterized by the fact that they couldn’t take adequate advantage of them.
• I’d say overall a step forward for Caleb Williams today. I thought his accuracy was better, especially considering the pressure he was under. His mobility outside the pocket was a huge difference in the game. And he drove teh team to a game winning touchdown under duress. Having said that, a better team would have won this game handily. Defensively the Bears feel like they are hanging on by a thread. Not many quarterbacks are gong to hand you 3 interceptions the way that Geno Smith did today but when you get them, you have to take advantage of them. Ands the lack of a running game continues to be worrying. A step towards competency at quarterback is a step toward the future for this team. For now, I guess you take that and the win and have a good week.

Offense

• Caleb WIlliams had forever to throw early in the game. Nice effort from the offensive line in that respect.
• Pretty surprised to see the trick play in the first quarter. They were pretty deep in their own territory so it was a gutsy play. It could’ve been a disaster.
• Nice to see Luther Burden involved in the game plan.
• It was really nice to see Williams complete those deep passes. His poor accuracy deep has, of course, been the major criticism of him and his career so far.
• Having said that, Williams accuracy really suffered this game. He didn’t look relaxed despite the fact that he got very good protection. I guess it’s just another one of those games where you grow. You hope so.
• It was halfway through the third quarter before DJ Moore had a catch. I was glad to see they got hm more involved after that.
• I was kind of surprised that Kyle Manangai didn’t see the ball until laid in the first half. I thought he’d be more a part of the plan earlier.
• It got better in the third quarter but the run game wasn’t great today. I kind of wondered if Ben Johnson didn’t start handing it to the wide receivers just to jump start it. To their credit, they ran off a lot of time in the second half with it.
• Despite the fact that the run game wasn’t particularly good, it was nice to see the play action pass work so well for the Bears. That has to be the heart of the offense.

Defense

• The Bears got blown off the ball again in this game. Dallas looked like they could run the ball almost any time they wanted. Every once in a while they brought 9 guys up to the line to try to stop it but you can’t do that every time.
• As usual, the opposition attacked Tyrique Stevenson despite the absence of Jaylon Johnson on the other side. That’s some disrespect that he has unfortunately earned. Of the two, I personally have less confidence in Nahshon Wright. Wright looked lost in coverage at a couple critical moments during the game.
• Those quick touchdowns early in the first quarter didn’t give the defense much of a rest. The Cowboys also went to the no huddle early. It did kind of make me wonder if they weren’t planning on eventually trying to wear the Bears down. The defense felt all day like a rickety ship that might sink at any moment.
• I did think that the defense put out a high effort today. They were all rallying to the ball all game.
• The pass rush wasn’t good again today. They need an answer to this. All of the warts from last week were very evident.
• As color man Tom Brady pointed out, the Bears had some success, crowding the line and faking the blitz, and then dropping it into coverage. Quarterback Dak Prescott had a bad habit of simply dumping the ball off in the face of the simulated pressure.

Miscellaneous

• The Bears kickoff returns seem like they are always shorter than they should be. The first drive stated on the 15.
• Nice play by Tyrique Stevenson literally taking the ball away from the Dallas running back early in the first quarter. That must be a dream play for any defensive player.
• 6 penalties for 41 yards is better but I think. It’s still too many. They occurred at critical times and would have really hurt in a closer game. They still have work to do here.
• The Bears won the turnover battle 3-0 and, as is usually th case, it had a huge influence on the game. I would dare say that the Bears defense might not have held it together without them.
• With comments about poor practice habits during the week, I was genuinely worried that Ben Johnson might start to lose the locker room if they’d lost this game, especially if they played poorly.

That said, it was very good to see the Bears take advantage of Dallas on a day when they played really poorly, especially on defense. I certainly have nothing against Matt Eberflus, who I think is a class individual, but he must already be under some pressure there. There was a lot of poor play on the defense, especially in the back field. The Bears offensive line was superb protecting Caleb Williams.??

Williams made progress today but I’m sure there will be words during the week about ways that he can improve his accuracy as, to my eye, he missed too many throws.

Defense

• This game was easy to figure out on the defensive side of the ball. The Lions offensive line dominated the line of scrimmage. Jared Goff had forever on to throw. They ran the ball far too easily.
• I wouldn’t say that the Lions ignored Jaylon Johnson while he was out there, they certainly did throw more to Tyrique Stevenson’s side of the field far more often. With a lot of success. The Bears have a corner back problem. Even when Johnson is out there.
• The Bears gave up far, far too many big plays today as the Lions racked up 500 yards of offense. Too many mistakes. Just too many.

Offense

• Caleb Williams looked good today, I thought. At least until things got out of hand and the game fell apart. He was usually on time and more or less accurate. For some of us, you can stop there and figure it was a good day. For the rest…
• It looked to me like it was tough going for the much touted inside of the Bears offensive line. There wasn’t a lot of room to run. Where they found it, it was off tackle and to the outside. Two Williams quarterback sneaks in the first half on the wrong side of the Bears forty yard line to turn the ball over on downs was good proof of that.
• Speaking of that turnover on downs, how many times have we seen head coaches try to show how tough the Bears are only to see it thrown back into their face in situations like this? I know that Ben Johnson wants to go for it on fourth down more but you have to use a little common sense. If the Bears were going to be able to sneak it across the line on fourth down, they would have been successful on third down. For heavens sake it might be a good statistical play for a mathematical guys but some teams are still going to be good at it and some teams aren’t. Make them prove it in less critical situations before you do something like that.
• The Bears had a false start in the first quarter and Williams waited until the last minute to throw the ball into the ground. He got hit. That was lazy and it shouldn’t happen.
• I was surprised that Williams spent so much time in the shot gun. Perhaps it’s easier to run the silent count from there but I would hope to see him more under center in the future. You can do play action from the shot gun – and they did. But it’s not as effective.
• Williams leaned a lot on Rome Odunze today, which is good. Honestly, he’s probably the Bears best receiver. But Olamide Zaccheaus is Williams’s safety valve, I think. When he needed a big third down, he seemed to be on the radar a lot. I think the Bears tried to force it just a bit to DJ Moore last game.

Miscellaneous

• A kickoff out of bounds handed the Lions far too easy field position in the first half.
• On a related note, the Lions appeared to winning the field position game. Special teams is a bit of an issue for this team early in the year, I think.
• The penalty count was eight but t felt like a lot more than that. Just repeated shooting themselves in the foot over and over again. It was frustrating to watch, especially early on.
• On a related note, does anyone still think all those false starts are WIlliams’ fault? Or maybe it’s his cadence on the silent count?
• The Bears lost the turnover battle. The fumble at the end of the first quarter. Killer. So many mistakes…
• Apparently it’s not enough for the Bears to give a game away themselves, the officials have to help out the Lions with an error at the end of the half. Nice.
• This game was a challenge to my assertion that the year is about Williams. He was better than last week. But the team…. So, so many mistakes. ??The only person in the world more frustrated watching this than the fans at home might have been Johnson. So many things to correct. It’s going to be a long year.

Brad Biggs at the Chicago Tribune answers your questions:

Is DJ Moore RB2 this week? — @nflchikennugget

I don’t think so. Rookie Kyle Monangai was on the field during the portion of practice Wednesday that was open to the media. I imagine there’s a decent chance the Bears will elevate Brittain Brown from the practice squad for Monday’s game, especially if Roschon Johnson, who wasn’t spotted at practice Wednesday, is unavailable.

I never saw a concept run away with the imagination of both fans and the media more than the idea that Moore might be the backup running back this week for the Bears. Or any kind of running back for that matter.

One of the main reasons why rookie running backs have a hard time getting on the field in the NFL is because they don’t know how to pass block. Even without Monangai or Johnson, I can’t imagine the Bears putting the protection of Caleb Williams into Moore’s hands. If Moore gets the ball as a running back at all, my guess is that it’s as no more than the occasional gimmick.

If I’m a defensive coordinator, I’m telling my guys that if they see Moore hit the backfield, it’s a pretty good guess he’s getting the ball. Because unless he’s running a pass route, it’s unlikely he’s going to be able to do much on the field without it in his hands.

Brad Biggs at the Chicago Trubune answers your questions

“Please articulate what you believe are Ben Johnson’s measures and key indicators of success for Caleb Williams. Help the casual fan understand how he will be evaluated so we know what to look for inside of this offense. — @2004_cjp”

“Johnson is looking for Williams to be comfortable and efficient playing on time and from the pocket. He looked like that in the second preseason game against the Bills, who rested their starters. He didn’t look like that in the preseason finale against the Chiefs starters. Does he regularly hit the top of his drop and — boom — deliver the ball on time and accurately? Does he efficiently work from his first to second and sometimes third reads? Is he comfortable climbing the pocket to create space and time to deliver a throw?

“Williams excels when it comes to second-reaction plays and operating outside the pocket and in the creative world. That stuff shines when he’s in the two-minute offense. To be an elite NFL quarterback, he has to be able to win from the pocket on a regular basis, and that was a struggle during his rookie season. Williams also needs to show a mastery of pre-snap assignments, which will help the Bears avoid some of the penalties they’ve had in camp and the preseason. The cleaner the operation is pre-snap, the better idea the quarterback will have of what the defense is doing post-snap.”

As I was reading this, I was thinking about an amusing section of a recent episode of The Bill Barnwell Show where Barnwell asked his guest, Gregg Rosenthal which of two seasons he thought Bears fans should prefer:

1. Bears go 8-9 but Caleb Williams is the 8th best quarterback in the league the second half of the season
2. Bears go 13-3 on the strength of their defense and make the playoffs.

Before the second scenario was described, even before Barnwell could even finish describing the first scenario, Rosenthal said, “That’s the season I want! I don’t care!” I could only laugh and nod my head.

Absolutely that’s the season we want. Bears fans know better than anyone that defensive success without a quarterback only leads to short-term gains. Williams being a top ten quarterback in the second half of the season means a long future of competitive football.

Being something of a downer by nature, there are visions of Mitch Trubisky‘s first pre-season game in my head as I think about Williams performance against Buffalo in this preseason. Trubisky looked exactly like Williams did and we all know that led nowhere.

Given that Williams first season was a complete organizational failure, I’ll more or less say the say same thing I said last year. No matter what the record in 2025, if Williams looks like that at all in the second half of the season, it will have been a success.

Brad Biggs at the Chicago Tribune has 10 thoughts after the Bears preseason finale:

The overriding theme for the offense throughout training camp was inconsistency, and I don’t think we saw a ton of explosive plays either (at least not as many as I would have expected). It’s going to take some time. No one expected this to be polished after three preseason games.

It was interesting after Friday’s game when [HC Ben] Johnson again mentioned the bye week, which comes in Week 5. Previously he talked about sorting through the left tackle situation until maybe the bye. He referenced it again in regard to the offense as a whole.

“We have plenty of time to assess what has gone on over the last few weeks and what direction we have to go here for the opening game,” he said. “To be honest with you, we might have to ebb and flow a little bit after that opening game. Usually it will take up until the bye week. I think it is placed at just the right time to identify who we are and what we are going to be for the rest of the season.”

Something tells me that the bye week is going to be optimistic.

Johnson’s offense reportedly took 12 practices to install, and they weren’t done until shortly before practices began against Buffalo. Probably, Johnson will choose to concentrate upon a subset of the plays that he thinks the team will be able to execute well to begin the season. But he installed them all for a reason.

Almost certainly related to the inconsistency, QB Caleb Williams‘s accuracy has also reportedly been an issue throughout camp. Just from the brief glimpses we got of him the last two games, especially the last one against Kansas City, I’d say he shows the signs of a man who is thinking and not reacting. Thinking about the play, thinking about the pre-snap look, thinking about his mechanics, thinking about everything. The head is connected to the arm, and when athletes do that, accuracy suffers.

I don’t think we’ll see the offense be all it can be, or Williams be all he can be, until at least halfway through the season when things slow down and become more natural to the participants. To be perfectly honest, I strongly suspect that it’s going to be more like halfway through next season.

There are going to be some rough times before that, and some people in the media will start to become very critical, especially of Williams, who is beyond his rookie grace period in his second year. In fact, it’s already started and it’s just the preseason.

My advice to fans would be to have patience. Williams has a lot of bad habits to leave behind, and it won’t happen overnight, especially in this new environment. We may not know for sure whether Williams and this offensive coaching staff are going to be able to help each other effectively for a long time yet.