Bear(ing) the News – A Chicago Bears Blog

Brad Biggs and Vaughn McClure at the Chicago Tribune note that Caleb Hanie was taking the snaps as the number 2 quarterback yesterday after yielding to Nathan Enderle on Monday.  He threw three interceptions:

“‘It’s not going well,’ Hanie said of training camp. ‘It’s just middle of the road. I’m still getting timing back and rhythm back and all that stuff.'”

The interceptions are OK.  In fact, at this point you might even say they’re natural.  But they are indicative of how far Hanie is behind in terms of running the offense.

No Bear needed the offseason more than Hanie and no Bear was more hurt by the labor stoppage that prevented him from getting the work he needed.  Hanie was injured during the first preseason game last year and lost valuable time learning how to handle the offensive coordinator Mike Martz‘s offense.  As a result, when he took over for Jay Cutler and Todd Collins, he ran the team more like a rookie than a third year pro.  Fans like to give Hanie credit for moving the ball against the Packers in the final playoff game but rarely mention the two devestating interceptions he threw.

Clearly Hanie was out of his depth last season and needed some hard coaching.  It was also clear last Saturday in the first preseason game that not getting it in the offseason was a problem.  Once again, instead of reading the defense, dropping back and throwing the ball to a spot, Hanie ran the offense like a Chinese fire drill.  I think its safe to say that Martz would have rather Hanie had done what he was supposed to and thrown interceptions than what he actually did.  Martz allows some of that from Cutler because he has to.  But he’s not going to tolerate it from Hanie and his displeasure was evident in the way he distributed the reps Monday.

You can’t have the rookie Enderle as your backup right now and Martz knows that.  The shame of it is that in terms of running the offense the way its supposed to be run, Enderle’s not that far behind Hanie.  That’s really bad with a questionable offensive line and Atlanta, New Orleans and Green Bay lined up in order to start the season.  We better all hope that by some miracle Cutler survives completely healthy or that Hanie gets a lot better very quickly.

I usually don’t write up game comments about pre-season games.  But I did find some interesting points:

1. No surprise, I thought the defensive line played well.  I was particularly happy with Henry Melton. I haven’t been on his band wagon but if he plays like that, I’m going to be a big fan.  Those 40 extra pounds he’s put on over his time as a Bear look good on him.
2. Its too bad we didn’t get to see Corey Wootton.  He’s another player who hasn’t impressed me in the past but who coaches have been raving about.  It would be wonderful to see him come through, too.
3. Vernon Gholston and Amobi Okoye might make significant contributions this year.  They weren’t much of a gamble and what I saw yesterday makes me think they might help.
4. Like everyone else, I think the offensive line needs work.  Roberto Garza was a bright spot in that, as far as I could tell, he played well.  I thought Carimi did a credible job given it was his first game.  Chris William‘s performance was unremarkable which I see as a good thing.  But J’Marcus Webb at left tackle was everything I feared he’d be and Lance Louis looks like he’s on the way to losing his job again.
5. Marion Barber runs very hard and did a good job. But yards aren’t everything.  He also looks heavy legged and I really do wonder if he’s got enough left.  Honestly, the way he’s running reminds me of Cedric Benson his last year with the Bears, making me wonder if those legs aren’t right after the injuries.
6. Line problems aside, the offense still isn’t running right. It looks like last year. Not… smooth? His time was limited but I don’t think Jay Cutler‘s throwing to spots like he’s supposed to (again).  We also saw last night why offensive coordinator Mike Martz isn’t thrilled with Caleb Hanie as the primary backup.  He definitely didn’t look good when he was asked to sit in the pocket and throw a pass greater than 8 yards. He looked confused and was holding the ball too long. Not that he had that much time to hold it… In any case if what we saw last night is typical, it’s pretty obvious they’re going to have to run heavily again this year if they don’t improve the passing attack.
7. The Bears were motioning Devin Hester into the slot (where he belongs).

Dan Pompei at the Chicago Tribune answers your questions:

“Why are the Bears starting Devin Hester and Roy Williams and benching Johnny Knox?… — Troy Oviedo, FL

“Hester is a better receiver than he gets credit for, and I think he’s still growing. He’s also probably been the most impressive receiver in Bears camp so far. Whenever I talk with opposing defensive coaches or pro scouts about the Bears offense, they consistently express concern about containing Hester. What I don’t get is the coaching staff anointing Williams a starter ahead of Knox. If Knox didn’t do anything to earn a starting job last year, Williams has done less to earn one this year. I understand Knox still is developing, but Knox had 430 more receiving yards than Williams last year, and his average per catch was 18.8 compared with 14.3 for Williams. It’s not like Williams has lit up camp, either.”

A few points here:

1)  Johnny Knox isn’t exactly being “benched”.  I’d say the Bears will be playing quite a lot in four wide receiver sets.  So it isn’t as if Knox is going to be spending entire games watching from the sideline.

2)  I’m wondering – and I’m pretty sure I’m not the only one – if Hester isn’t finally going to be playing more in the slot where many, most notably offensive coordinator Mike Martz, think he should be playing.  When Martz arrived in town one of the first things he said was that Hester would be great in the slot only to be almost immediately shot down by head coach Lovie Smith.

3)  Martz comments about Knox being given the job last year have little to do with Williams.  Whatever else you can say about Williams, he’s a veteran in the league who has shown he can compete.  I’ve got a suspicion that Knox’s stock is way down specifically because the job the Packers did on him.  They really beat him up off the line of scrimmage and the Bears are probably particularly concerned that it happened twice.  To be frank, while watching the games I thought the Packers took Knox’s spirit and he simply quit.  In any case he certainly didn’t fight for the ball the way anyone would have liked to see him do for much of the year.  We’ll get to see what he’s made of now that he’s competing for playing time.

The wide receivers should be very interesting to watch tonight.  As Brad Biggs, also at the Tribune, pointed out today, “If one free-agent addition hits it big, the Bears hope it’s Roy Williams.”  No matter what the organization maintains, they weren’t going to beat the Packers with the same group at the same positions as last year.

Bears

• I kind of figured Matt Forte would be too good of a team player to hold out.  Let’s hope the Bears take care of him.  Via Mark Potash at the Chicago Sun-Times:

‘‘It never benefits a player or a team for somebody to hold out,’’ Forte said. ‘‘But I kind of got my mind put at ease by Jerry. He said that a deal would get done. He assured us repeatedly that a deal would get done. Where I’m from and how I was raised, when someone gives you their word, it goes a long way.’’

Brad Biggs at the Chicago Tribune has a good comment on the Forte situation:

“Contract extensions are the trickiest of deals to do says Jerry Angelo.

“That’s because when a player is on the open market, the natural process sets a value for the player.”

This one is going to be worse than most.  Forte has gotten a fair bit of attention in the press and its upping his value, probably to a higher level than it should be, and Angelo knows it.  The agent is going to want more than Forte should probably get and its going to cause trouble.

• Dan Pompei at the Chicago Tribune gets the scoop on new Bears wide receiver Sam Hurd, who is likely a Rashied Davis replacement:

“’He can play,’ former Cowboys receivers coach Ray Sherman told the Tribune.  ’He has a great work ethic and is smart. Tough. He has no fear. He’s a great special teams player. He probably was the best special teams player there, and he played very well at receiver too.’”

• Matt Bowen at the National Football Post wonders how much new Bears receiver Roy Williams will help the Bears:

“Is it really an upgrade? I can’t call Williams a No.1 in the NFL (and I still view [Johnny] Knox as the top WR in Chicago), but the Bears get a player with a different skill set to add to their roster. If he can make some plays in [Mike] Martz’s offense, this will be an addition that pays off. Let’s see how if plays out in camp and during the regular season first.”

Williams tells Potash why Chicago was a good fit for him:

‘‘’To be back with [Mike] Martz and coach [Darryl] Drake is a blessing for me,’ said Williams, 29, who signed a one-year contract with the Bears after being released by the Dallas Cowboys. ‘To go to a system that I already know, that I’ve had success in — it was a pretty easy decision.’”

I heard a lot of snarky comments about the Bears claiming reclamation projects over the weekend.  But in nearly every case there was a reason why the Bears thought the players were a fit for them and would improve because of it.  They weren’t just picking up random failures.  It was a methodical approach.  For instance, Michael C. Wright at ESPNChicago.com points out why Vernon Gholston might do better in Chicago than he did in New York:

“Gholston played linebacker in Rex Ryan’s 3-4 system when the coach took over the Jets in 2009, before moving back to defensive end in 2010, a position — because of the scheme — still a world apart from what he’d been used to in the Buckeyes’ 4-3 defense.”

Gholston and Amobi Okoye both weren’t fits for their respective defenses.  Williams is reunited with Martz.  There are reasons why these guys might rehabilitate their careers here.

• David Haugh at the Chicago Tribune thinks Jay Cutler may be trying to under go a change in demeanor.  Many will recall that I said the same thing last year.  It didn’t last.
• In what everyone agrees is a critical camp for Marcus Harrison, he once again showed up overweight and couldn’t workout with the team.  Not good.  Via McClure and Biggs.
• Sean Jensen at the Chicago Sun-Times on new Bears center Chris Spencer:

“If the new guy replaces the old guy — the longest-tenured player who was beloved throughout the organization — then Spencer constantly will get compared to Kreutz.

“And, according to NFC West scouts, the styles couldn’t be more contrasting.

“Three of them said Spencer is bright, with one describing him as an ‘All-American kid.’ There’s also no denying that he’s big and athletic (6-3, 309 pounds). He also has shown himself to be tough, playing through injuries, oftentimes the shoulder. But he wasn’t considered a core leader in Seattle, and the Seahawks let him go, in part, because he didn’t have one trait that Kreutz had in spades: nastiness.”

• Potash at the Chicago Sun-Times quotes J’Marcus Webb:

“Offensive tackle J’Marcus Webb, a seventh-round draft pick in 2010 who became a starter as a rookie last season, is hoping to make even bigger strides this year.

‘‘’Definitely the Pro Bowl,’ Webb said.”

• McClure thinks the Bears might be in play for free agent cornerback Pat Hayden.

Elsewhere

• Mike Florio at profootballtalk.com points out that many first round picks still aren’t signed despite the rookie wage scale.  It appears that Adrian Clayborn’s deal is gumming up the works.
• The Superficial thinks that Kristin Cavallari finally found the Xanax.

One Final Thought

Former Bears scouting director Greg Gabriel at the National Football Post explains that the  Bears needed to ignore the decline in play and resign Olin Kreutz for his leadership ability.  Most of us tend to agree, I think, but the emotional upheaval amongst members of the media yesterday bordered on ridiculous.  Biggs almost seemed to be going through the five stages of grief before our eyes on Twitter and even Angelo had to remind them that no one had died.

Sometimes things just don’t work out.  The likelihood is that the Bears are now a little better at the line of scrimmage and a little worse as a team.  We’re all sorry to see it but its not the end of the world.

In one of the most interesting features to the day, at least to me, Dan Pompei at the National Football Post asks agent of the quarterback stars Leigh Steinberg about how he identifies quarterback talent.  I recommend reading all of it but I thought it might be worth highlighting a few of what I thought were his unique insights:

“A quarterback has to be able to be able to elevate his play in the clutch. Steinberg talks about wanting his QBs to have a ‘quiet mind’ when the volume is turned up. ‘Most games are close,’ he said. ‘They often come down to one drive. When a quarterback has thrown interceptions, his team is behind, and he has to be perfect on a final drive, what does he do? That’s so important. You want a quiet mind. I used to see Ben Roethlisberger multitask—he would watch TV, take five phone calls, be on his computer. But he could tune out every extraneous thing, and focus on task at hand. He has a quiet mind.’”

“Strong roots make for sturdy branches. In 1993, Steinberg was in the pole position to land Rick Mirer. Then he met [Drew] Bledsoe. And he met Bledsoe’s family. Bledsoe’s father Mac especially impressed Steinberg. As a result, Steinberg chose to pursue Bledsoe instead of Mirer. ‘I saw the stability and security from that family, and how his father was a great motivator,’ Steinberg said. ‘We look at that aspect of a player’s background, his bloodlines. When I met Jim Harbaugh’s father, I knew what we had there. Steve Young’s father [LeGrande] played at Brigham Young and his nickname was ‘Grit.’’

“Willingness to be a role model reveals character. Steinberg only wanted players who would give back. ‘If they are interested in retracing their roots, they tend to be of high character,’ he said.”

When I look at many of the quarterbacks that have failed over the course of my lifetime, most didn’t have many or most of these characteristics.  If you want a good example, Vince Young is the poster boy.  On the other hand most of the greats had these characteristics.  They’re obviously very general rules but they certainly seem to be legitimate characteristics to look for.